AMERICAN IDOL 2011 TOP 9: THE SHOCKING RESULTS NIGHT

Last year, nobody was expecting Siobhan Magnus' departure after she received good comments from the judges with her performance of "Any Man of Mine" on Shania Twain week.

This year, who would expect that this Idol contestant would leave earlier than Paul McDonald, Haley Reinhart, and Stefano Langone?

So now, the question is would she beat the American idol winner this year? Hopefully, she will. Other questions that tickled my mind would be WHERE ARE YOU BASING YOUR VOTES? WHY WAS SHE ELIMINATED? WHY CAN'T THE JUDGES DECIDE WHO WILL BE ELIMINATED BETWEEN THE BOTTOM 2 FOR A FAIR GAME TO THE BETTER SINGERS IN THE COMPETITION?

Other than being the shocking results night, this is the most boring results night.

The guest of the night was Constantine Maroulis singing "Unchained Melody" and Iggy Pop singing "Wild Child"

Stefano was the first one to be in the bottom three, while Casey Abrams and Lauren Alaina were the first ones to be sent to safety. Pia followed Stefano in the bottom three, while Paul McDonald and Scotty McCreery were sent to safety. It was Jacob Lusk who completed the bottom three, making Haley and James safe.

The last part of the show was really shocking because it was announced that Pia Toscano is the one eliminated.

THE TOP 8 with Pia, Thia, Naima, Karen, and Ashton.

Who is happy about the results now? Not Ryan Seacrest. Not the judges. Not Pia's fans. Not the Americans who voted for other contestants but loved her.

Two girls left, and the guys still strong with none of them being eliminated.

Did America get it right? NO. PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT